A few quick observations on the first debate between Senators McCain and Obama:
Barack Obama showed a comfort and command of the issues. We of course disagreed with the substance of most of his positions, but just in terms of his delivery, he came across well. That alone probably makes it a win for Obama, although McCain was good most of the way too, so it wasn’t by any means a knock-out blow for Obama. Given McCain’s narrative that he’s the one with decades of foreign policy experience and Obama is an inexperienced rookie, the expectations were on McCain to excel in the debate. He did well, but didn’t score a knock-out.
What was most striking to us was that McCain seemed to fail to play many of the cards he had available to him, especially early on, he seemed to hesitate to go after Obama.
For example, Obama in the first few minutes laid the blame for the current economic crisis on the Bush administration and a “no regulation” ideology. McCain failed to go after Obama’s big donations from Fannie Mae, his ties to Fannie Mae CEOs, his failure to do anything about the issue before now (hitting the “talk is cheap” theme), the inaction of the Democrats and their support of loosening lending standards that lead to the crisis at Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, and the fact that the administration and Senator McCain sponsored legislation years ago to try to tighten regulation of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. He left all of it off the table, a lot of glaring and important omissions.
McCain should have pointed out that Obama is trying to buy votes with his “tax cuts for 95%” scam – 95% of the people don’t pay income taxes, Obama is talking about sending checks to people. That’s spending, not a tax cut. Obama also referred to actual tax cuts as “spending” at one point; a typical lefty, he doesn’t understand whose money he’s talking about.
McCain should have noted that Obama wants to raise taxes on energy producers, which will increase energy prices, including the price of gasoline.
On McCain’s support of the initial invasion of Iraq, he should have quickly pointed out that Joe Biden also voted to authorize military force in Iraq, that there was broad bipartisan agreement for the authorization to use military force and broad bipartisan agreement that Iraq was a national security threat and a state sponsor of terrorism, and that Obama was in no position to do anything on the issue in 2002, but that he’s been wrong on the issue ever since he joined the Senate and actually had a vote on the issue, which is what matters – doing, not talking.
McCain should have pointed out that the notion we’ve been focused solely on Iraq is a ludicrous and vacuous talking point from Obama.
Obama kept claiming that the Bush administration opposed any diplomacy with North Korea. This is a lie. The administration pursued multi-lateral talks with North Korea, the approach the Democrats usually demand, when their not engaging in disingenuous, knee-jerk opposition to the Bush administration.
Wit that little anecdote about Kenya, was Obama saying that immigrants don’t want to come to America any more? Our “reputation in the world” is soiled among the elitist international left. immigrants still want to come to America by the millions.
McCain did better as the debate went on, and finished strong. That may help him a great deal in the overall reaction. People will remember the end more than the beginning.