Pavlovian cries of “racism” from the unthinking left are as surprising as the Sun rising every morning, but they’re still irritating. A classic example comes at the expense of Newt Gingrich, who recently apologized, en español, for some ill-chosen words about English immersion vs. bilingual education. Mr. Gingrich initially said:
“We should replace bilingual education with immersion in English,” he told the [National Federation of Republican Women] last weekend, “so people learn the common language of the country and they learn the language of prosperity, not the language of living in a ghetto.”
Gingrich claims, and it’s reasonable to believe, that he was referring to a “ghetto” in the sense of an isolated enclave, not in the sense the word is often used in the U.S. today, to refer to a poor, often ethnically segregated neighborhood. But the word choice was obviously not the best. A speaker has to be cognizant of the common usage of words, and how those words will be perceived by the wider audience.
However, there’s no basis at all to claim Gingrich’s statement was “hateful” or “racist” or had anything at all to do with race. Unfortunately, for so many on the left, everything has to do with race.
Washington Post Staff Writer Jose Antonio Vargas shows his biased true colors early in his snarky “report” about Gingrich’s apology with the line:
The apology was delivered in English and Spanish, with the three-minute Spanish video, “Mensaje de Newt Gingrich,” subtitled in English. Can’t get any more bilingual than that.
(However: Memorando al Señor Gingrich: In Spanish, the “r” is rolled and the syl-la-bles are se-pa-ra-ted.)
We’re absolutely sure Mr. Vargas would have no problemo whatsoever if a conservative were to offer a similar flippant correction to a Latino immigrant who didn’t speak his newly learned English with a perfect American accent. Right. And we are the King of Spain.
The remarks drew a barrage of comments from the Latino community…
Actually, from a few members of the left-leaning, grievance-mongering “Latino community.”
…and were quickly repudiated on popular Web sites such as Latin Americanist, Latino Pundit and Vivir Latino– U.S. Latino life in blog form. A headline on Vivir Latino read “Newt — Not Ghetto Fabulous,” with Maegan Ortiz, the site’s New York-based editor, writing: “Don’t you love how politicos use Spanish when it works for them and when it doesn’t, they trash it?” Similarly, Hispanic organizations such as the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund were incredulous, calling Gingrich’s comments “hateful.”
“There is a clear understanding among Latino citizens and Latino immigrants that you must learn English to get good jobs, to fully participate in this society. There is no resistance to that fact,” said Peter Zamora, a credentialed bilingual education teacher who is the co-chairman of the Washington-based Hispanic Education Coalition, which supports bilingual education.
Added Ortiz, who, like Zamora, watched Gingrich’s mea culpa Wednesday night: “It’s just so ironic that he’d use a video spoken in his ghetto Spanish to say sorry about a nasty, racist remark directed at the Latino community. I mean this is a guy whose own official Web site has his own biography written in Spanish. How hypocritical is that?”
It’s left unexplained by these activists how exactly the remarks were racist or hateful. That’s because there’s no basis at all for these thoughtless, knee-jerk responses. There’s no connection between race and language. None. Which race speaks English? Which race speaks Spanish? How is it in any way “hateful” to wish that people who live in the United States learn English and thus gain greater success in life? We’d call such thinking twisted, except it’s obvious no actual thought went into their remarks.
And of course no liberal can go more than five minutes without accusing someone who disagrees with him of hypocrisy. But again, it is left totally unexplained how it is the least bit hypocritical for Gingrich, who speaks English every well, to advocate that all Americans learn to speak English well.
Mr. Gingrich misspoke, and then he reached out to those he offended and apologized. Decent, fair-minded people should accept his apology. The Perpetually Offended Left will of course never do so.